
ANTHOLOGY 1 : When this album came out in 1995, including the DVD, the whole world, included yours, truly waited with bated breath and who wouldn't. After all it's The bloody Beatles and it was more than 25 years since their last album 'Let It Be'. Was the wait and the hype worth it ? Yes and no. Well if you can sit through the few atrocious but historical tracks, you'll find yourself rewarded with the treasure doves of Beatles heavens. You'll see the way The Beatles work, the work in progress of songs that were transformed into the masterpieces that we all knew and loved so much. The single, Free As A Bird, although it did unite the late John Lennon with Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr was hardly 'In My Life' or 'Let It Be' standard. But since this is after all a Beatles album and for that reason alone, it demands a listen and the world did listen sending the album and the subsequent two other anthology albums into No.1. A word of caution though, this is not for casual fans.
Disc 1
Free As A Bird ( John Lennon ) : This track comes with big baggage. The first ever Beatles record in 25 years. Amid all the hype, one thing is certain, the world have not forgotten The Beatles. They still loves them unquestionably. Personally I don't care too much for this song. The novelty is that technically it's The Beatles and that's all it holds for me. The song as a whole is really not Beatles standard. John could write better songs in his sleep. This sounds rather like funeral music. Paul should have known better. The video is something else though. Filled to the blink with characters from Beatles songs, it's a visual treat for Beatles fans. Totally loved it. I would sit through the whole torturous song just to watch the video.
Speech : John : Just like what it says, a speech by John Lennon.
That'll Be The Day ( Jerry Allison / Buddy Holly / Norman Petty ) : An amateurish recording made by the pre Beatles boys, John, Paul & George and sounded exactly like it was. Amateurish. I wouldn't recommend this to new comers. A friend of mine was curious by this group 'cos of the huge publicity in the newspapers, radios and TVs. He wasn't English literate by the way. Anyway, he was curious enough to give it a listen. He couldn't go pass the the fourth tracks and I don't blame him.
In Spite Of All The Danger ( Paul McCartney / George Harrison ) : Same as the above and cut on the same day. It's a novelty track for me. I wouldn't have bother to listen if it wasn't for the Beatles' name, but historically, it's priceless. We get to hear the boys before they transformed into music Gods.
Speech : Paul McCartney : Another speech, this time by Paul.
Hallelujah, I Love Her So ( Ray Charles ) : The boys in the mist of developing their sounds. Historical value only. Non Beatles fans stay away.
You'll Be Mine ( John Lennon / McCartney ) : Honestly, this has got to be the worst Lennon / McCartney composition ever put on paper.
Chayenne : ( Paul McCartney ) : An instrumental by Paul.
Speech : Paul : Another speech.
My Bonnie ( Traditional arranged by Tony Sheridan ) : Another historical track. This one got the boys noticed by Brian Epstein who gave them their first big break. A slight hitch was that Paul's speech was mingled into the song so we couldn't have it as a stand alone track but this track can be found in other compilation. The boys were only doing the backing for Tony Sheridan and they in turn were credited as The Beat Brothers. Technically The Beatles did not exist at this time.
Ain't She Sweet ( Milton Ager / Jack Yellen ) : John Lennon delivered this track which would not be out of place in their first album "Please Please Me". A pleasant track just right for the time.
Cry For A Shadow ( George Harrison / John Lennon ) : This is a rare one in that it featured the sole writing credits of John Lennon and George Harrison in any Beatles albums. An instrument in the mould of The Shadows. Nice.
Speech : John : Speech time.
Speech : Brian Epstein : Speech time again.
Searching ( Jerry Leiber / Mike Stoller ) : The first of five songs performed by the boys for their Decca audition. This first number by The Coasters was not really the best of version. The Hollies have a hit with this song.
Three Cool Cats ( Jerry Liber / Mike Stoller ) : The next song for the audition. Considering the standard of this track, you can't really blame the guy for choosing The Tremeloes over them.
The Sheik Of Araby ( Harry B. Smith / Francis Wheeler / Ted Snyder ) : This third cover didn't flared any better.
Like Dreamers Do ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : One of the numerous Lennon / McCartney songs which The Beatles never released while the group was in existence. This was given to The Applejacks, a UK pop group. I, somehow prefer The Applejacks's version to this version.
Hello Little Girl ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This was solely written by John Lennon although credited to Lennon / McCartney but was given to The Fourmost to cover, which was no great shake either. Ditto The Beatles version.
Speech : Brian Epstein : Speech time again by Brian.
Besame Mucho ( Consuelo Velazquez / Sunny Skylar ) : Paul's turn at the mike. Not the best version I've heard so far.
Love Me Do ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : Yet another version of 'Love Me Do' but this time the drumming was by Pete Best. The other two versions, the drummers were Alan White and Ringo Starr. From this point on, the CD is getting interesting 'cos we are finally venturing into Beatles territory.
How Do You Do It ( Mitch Murray ) : This was the track that George Martin wanted them to record and release as a single. The Beatles were persistent in not releasing a song not written by them. So they recorded this so not as to ruffle the feather of George Martin. Both were proven right with their choice. The Beatles were well on their way with 'Love Me Do' while 'How Do You Do It' was a No.1 for Gerry and the Pacemakers. Wouldn't say I like this song a lot but it's a lot better than a few of the songs from that album.
Please Please Me ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : I don't particularly like this song due to overkill so it's kind of pleasant to hear a different version of this song.
One After 909 [ Sequence ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : First heard on the "Let It Be" album, this track was actually an 'old' number that they composed before they became famous. This version was uncompleted. I never care much for this song anyway.
One After 909 [ complete ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This was supposed to be the master but somehow the boys were not totally pleased with it so it was never released until this anthology. Clearly the "Let It Be" version was the more superior take with another of John's song added to it.
Lend Me Your Comb ( Kay Twomey / Fred Wise / Ben Weisman ) : This was recorded after The Beatles have achieved considerable success with their first album. Tapped for the BBC radio series together with 'That's All Right, Mama', 'Carol', 'Soldier Of Love' and 'Clarabella' which were all on the "Live At The BBC' album. This track hence is released here for the first time. Can't say I am thrilled by it though.
I'll Get You ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : Another version of one of my favorite Beatles' song.
Speech : John : John speaking to Jann Wenner of Rolling Stone magazine on the 8th, December 1970, New York City. A chilling date for those who knows.
I Saw Her Standing There ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : The Beatles performing live on Sweden radio. Straight forward no nonsense kick ass rock 'n' roll as good as it can get. No matter how many times or how many versions of this song I've heard, I never grow tired of it.
From Me To You ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : John on lead here with the boys backing on this equally good performance. What's missing is the harmonica which was so prominence on the original version.
Money [ That's What I Want ] ( Berry Gordy Jr / Janie Bradford ) : John again with this 'With The Beatles' album closer. I think I like this much better than the album version.
You Really Got A Hold On Me ( William "Smokey" Robinson ) : My favorite non Lennon / McCartney track. As many times as I have heard of their version of this song, this is still as good as the next.
Roll Over Beethoven ( Chuck Berry ) : George turn on lead..Not really a favorite of mine but still it's worth a listen if only to compare it with the album version.
Disc 2
She Loves You ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This was one of the tracks performed at the celebrated 1963 Royal Command Performance on the 4th of November 1964, where John's super sharp wit was first in display.
Till There Was You ( Meredith Willson ) : Paul McCartney could always be counted upon to give a heart stirring performance of a ballad at any concert and this was no exception. To their credits, their singing and especially the guitar interlude sounds almost the same as on the record.
Twist And Shout ( Bert Russell / Phil Medley ) : John's much celebrated dig at the establishment can be heard here. " For the last number, I'd like to ask your help", John challenged. "Would the people in the cheaper seats clap your hands ? And the rest of you, if you'll just rattle your jewellery".......
This Boy ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : On this track, the boys demonstrated their mastery at harmonizing and they don't disappoint.
I Want To Hold Your Hand ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This track, though first heard more than 32 years ago, still sound as fresh and infectious as ever. I couldn't help shaking my hip listening to this while driving much to the amusement of the other drivers looking on who must have thought I was on drug or something. Small wonder America falls for The Beatles.
Speech : Eric Morecombe and Ernie Wise : The Beatles on The Morecambe And Wise Show which was a meeting of two teams at the top, Eric Morecambe, the jokester and Ernie Wise, his straight man who were Britain's favorite comic team.
Moonlight Bay ( Edward Madden / Percy Wenrich ) : Eric Morecombe and Ernie Wise singing with The Beatles. Strictly a novelty song.
Can't Buy Me Love ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This was another version of 'Can't But Me Love' with Paul goofing around not remember the words to his own song. Credits to them for being able to carry on the song in spite of not remember the lyric.
All My Loving ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : The first song from The Beatles historical appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show. Again credits to the boys for being able to transfer almost note by note the song especially the guitar bridge in the middle which is almost identical to the record.
You Can't Do That ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This version was actually recorded for inclusion in "A Hard Day's Night' movie but for some reason of other it was left off the movie and was placed in the non soundtrack track of the record. A nice version anyway.
And I Love Her ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This was clearly a work in progress of Paul's first beautiful ballad. It was still without the middle part which was added in later. Although not yet completed, the beauty of the song cannot be denied.
A Hard Day's Night ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : Take 1 of this famous song. The instrumental bridge was different from the version that we knew so well. Still, a great song is a great song.
I Wanna Be Your Man ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : Ringo's track from "With The Beatles". I've never really like this number but strangely I liked this live version. Probably due to over familiarity with the song as with lots of Beatles songs.
Long Tall Sally ( Enotris Johnson / Richard Penniman / Robert Blackwell ) : Like the above, I liked this live version more than the studio version.
Boys ( Luther Dixon / Wes Farrell ) : See above.
Shout ( Rudolph Isley / Ronald Isley / O'Kelly Isley ) : This track was never released commercially by The Beatles during their time. Well, I don't think we are missing much anyway. There's a autobiography book of the group by this name, by the way.
I'll Be Back [ Take 2 ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : The Beatles working in the studio. A slow take as compare to the finished product.
I'll Be Back [ Take 3 ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This is more like the finished product. Interesting insight into the way The Beatles' work with their swift change of idea of a song from waltz like to up tempo.
You Know What To Do ( George Harrison ) : George's second song after 'Don't Bother Me'. A lukewarm number which was understandably never issued until now.
No Reply [ Demo ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : The Beatles demoed their new song for "Beatles For Sale". An interesting take.
Mr. Moonlight ( Roy Lee Johnson ) : I don't know why this song got such a bad reputation. It was often referred to as one of the worst Beatles song ever recorded but I love it. The album version and now this version. I love singing this with my band too.
Leave My Kitten Alone ( Little Willie John / Titus Turner / James McDougal ) : This was another non Lennon / McCartney number which was supposed to be included in the "Beatles For Sale" album but due to some reasons or other it never was released until now.
No Reply ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : This was closer to the album version but deemed unsuitable due to John's laughter which showed the fun The Beatles were having as they were working.
Eight Days A Week [ Sequence ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : An invaluable look at The Beatles at work.
Eight Days A Week [ Complete ] ( John Lennon / Paul McCartney ) : Almost done here.
Kansas City / Hey Hey Hey Hey ( Jerry Leiber / Mike Stoller / Richard Penniman ) : As with the studio version on "Beatles For Sale", I don't really like the rockier non Lennon / McCartney number but somehow I find this version here more tolerable.
DOP : Unknown.